1605 N FARES AVE Evansville, IN 47711

Highlights from our reviews are shared below. All reviews can be viewed on the respective review sites.

Page: 1 of 3 (15 reviews)

Sort By:
Per Page:

Melanie Ford

05/12/2025
5.00

Buying a used car can feel like a gamble—but with Randy, it felt more like a win. He was completely honest and upfront about everything, which made the entire process feel less like a transaction and more like a collaboration. We were shopping for our son, and he helped us find something safe, reliable, and within our budget—no pressure, no games. I’ve dealt with big dealerships before and ended up with buyer’s remorse a week later. This was the exact opposite. It’s rare to find people in this business who truly care and stand by what they sell—but that’s exactly what you’ll get here. We drove away with peace of mind and a great car at a fair price. I trust them, and that says a lot.

Jo Douglas

05/08/2025
5.00

Great customer service! I had the car checked out for due diligence and received a good report. I'm so glad that I found Polen's Buy It Rite!

Michael Guitreau

05/08/2025
5.00

Randy was very professional and honest. I would highly recommend doing business with him. Go get your next ride you will be in and out in no time.

HARLEY WEBB

05/08/2025
5.00

Victoria Tyra

08/17/2024
5.00

Great cars, honest bargaining! A rare treat for a female car buyer! They treated me like a member of the family!

P L

08/16/2024
5.00

Melissa Millsap

04/12/2024
5.00

Randy was very honest and up front about everything he knew about each car we looked at. He helped us find something that worked for our daughter. We have purchased used cars from large dealerships and had issues the next week that they would not fix. Anytime you buy used, it can be a gamble. Finding someone who is as honest with you as possible and fair is the best you can hope for. I am happy with our experience and the vehicle we bought. I think we got a good car for a good price.

Doc Brown

01/12/2024
5.00

Got a great deal from them on an 87 Allante. I've been looking for a decent deal on one for years, and finally found it here! They were nice, and easy to deal with. Even sent one of his employees on a fairly long drive to help me get the car home. I've never bought from a car lot before, and was pleasantly surprised. Would definitely give them my business again in the future.

Troy Maggard

11/16/2021
5.00

patsy hill

05/06/2021
5.00

Page: 1 of 3 (15 reviews)

Customer Testimonials for Polen's Buy It Rite Auto

Testimonial Photo

Shanda Hillery - 2021 awesome best to get

Randy is awesome and he does his best to get you in something. This baby is mine. Thank you Randy for everything...

Testimonial Photo

Felicia Sanners - 2021 Great Place

Great place to purchase your first car

Testimonial Photo

Kishor Patel - 2022 honest and Reliable Ready to help

Nice honest and too much reliable person. Ready to help. Only facts and no cheating. Best priced place for purchase of first car.

Text Us